Answers

A cheaper balena alternative for devices that are already deployed

balena updates whole images and needs balenaOS. If you mostly need access, health and commands on the OS you already run, the options are different.

Asked on Hacker News, July 2022: “Ask HN: Favorite IoT Fleet Management Tool/Service”

Short answer

First decide what you need. Atomic OS and container updates mean an image-based tool such as balena, Mender or Pantavisor, and a reflash. Reaching devices, watching their health and running commands on the OS they already run doesn't need any of that, and costs much less.

Image-based tools replace the OS; an agent-based tool works on the OS that is already there.Your devicesDebian, Pi OS, YoctoAgentone static binaryFieldhand relayrelay.fieldhand.devYour teamshell · health · commandsno reflashoutbound :443browser
Image-based tools replace the OS; an agent-based tool works on the OS that is already there.

Two kinds of tools

  • Image-based: balena (balenaOS plus containers), Mender (A/B partitions, usually on Yocto), Pantavisor, or hawkBit with SWUpdate. You get atomic updates with rollback. You also rebuild your image around them and reflash every unit, which is hard for devices already at customer sites.
  • Agent-based: install on the running OS. qbee and Fieldhand work this way, and Ansible over SSH does too if the devices are reachable. You get access, monitoring and scripted changes, but no atomic image swap.

Where Fieldhand fits

One command per device, no reflash, no containers: browser shell and your own ssh, health and offline alerts, fleet commands in waves that stop on failures, files, the screen of a kiosk, and the device's own web pages. $1.50 per device that connected in the month, the first 5 free. It doesn't replace your OS update mechanism; if you need atomic image updates, use an image-based tool, and Fieldhand alongside it for access if you like.

Comparisons with prices: Fieldhand vs balena. Try it on a live fleet: read-only demo.

By Abner Souza, who builds Fieldhand. Updated 2026-10-23. Something wrong or out of date? Write to support@fieldhand.dev.

Something wrong or missing on this page? Tell us.